I'm part of several online groups for writers, and I poll them for time to time when I am struggling with how to tackle my latest writing challenge. Many of the responses I received were witty, many were sincere, and many just were profound. I thought I would share some of the responses to this question:
"Being a writer is at bottom, in its purest form, being a story-teller. Our true heritage is in the early days of man, as we sat around a campfire and told tales of the day’s adventures … and misadventures. We are those story-tellers. What we need most is that campfire. "
"Not an alchoholic, but you do have to drink coffee. Lots of coffee."
"I have done some of my best writing on a bottle of red ;) In saying that, my writing doesn't come from the bottom of a bottle of cabernet merlot - my writing comes from within me :) "
"I think a lot of writers do write from pain and use writing as a way to "exorcise their demons". But I think we don't all take to drink or drugs because we come from a different compulsion. We want to share something. It doesn't seem to be enough for us to know or understand. We have to expose it to others for it to have real meaning for us."
"well you need to be drunk and high but liquor is not the answer you need to drink yourself. Pour your heart out in a glass (maybe)... just take a sip of yourself your true self actually, get high... in your spirits and write.... we feel down many at times and it may cause the writer's block (or whatever) so take a sip or two whenever you want to but slowly.. hold .. smell your words... and when you feel the freshness in them again... write.
we sip we write and we sip again...
and enjoy! :] "
"". . . moody, difficult, glum, or a little mad." Right. Add a few stiff drinks to that and you should really get a lot of work done. Oh, those romantic fantasies. All the studies, interviews, research have long since shown that folks get the writing done in SPITE of those psychological problems. And that is heroic.
There might well be some neurological link for some writers that connects with creativity, but the substance abuse/depression myth has become a pretty tired cliche.
Booze, drugs, sex and rock and roll may be a lot of fun - - go for it; just don't fool yourself that it will all make you a better writer. Of course it could give you some good material. . "
"As writers, we have many voices inside us, people with stories demanding release. This sets us apart. Some writers, in dealing with this, turn to drinking or other outlets, but that's not what makes a good writer. In fact, it has crushed many a good writer. Good writing (and rewriting) do demand a conduit to the subconcious, but there are many better ways of getting there than drinking. "
"I heard that Tina Brown segment, and to a degree, I think she's right.
What writing requires, especially fiction or narrative history, is a lowering of inhibitions, letting go of the inner critic that says "this is wrong" or "I feel squeamish writing about this character or situation" That's where all the good stuff is: passion, ambition, seething rage, or whatever it is your characters require. Inhibited writers don't write very interesting stuff because it isn't very deep.
Now, alcohol helps with lowering one's inhibitions, but what Tina doesn't know (Tennesse Williams and William Saroyan didn't either) is that you don't have to abuse your liver to get the same effect"
"Writers do tend to be a cantankerous lot, and alcoholics are contankerous too, but I don't think that just because A=B and B=C that A necessarily equals C in this case. All people are inherently messed up, it's what you do with that in your life that really counts. Writing can be a form of therapy, you can work out your demons (or sic them on your characters) and spend a little time in a different world. Having tried it both ways, I can definitively report that my writing doesn't benefit from over consumption of alcohol. Be kind to your liver and your editor and avoid chemical dependency."
" have to confess that I feel a certain wistfulness for the days when writers sat in cafes drinking and lived debauched lives. I come from a culture where there's more drinking anyway and many of our finest Irish writers were fond of a drink. It doesn't seem to have prevented them from creating masterpieces.
As some of the previous posts said, it has to do with letting go of inhibitions. Some great writers are colourful characters and drink tends to contribute to that colour. And I think some of that colour is missing. I just can't help but feel that the ability to enjoy a drink (not too many) is a sign of a person who is willing to let go a little and engage with the world. I don't think you need to be an alcoholic to be a good writer, but letting a little bonhomie into your life will give your writing a more rounded quality. "